What is the most accurate level sensor?

30 Dec.,2024

 

Most Reliable Liquid Level Sensors

Choosing the right liquid level sensor ensures optimal process control. Icon Process Controls offers a variety of reliable liquid level sensors for different applications. This blog covers the working principles, features, benefits, and applications of hydrostatic (submersible), radar, ultrasonic, and float level sensors. We&#;ll discuss the specific models: LevelPro 100 Series, LevelPro ProScan 3 80 GHz Radar, LevelPro UltraPro Ultrasonic, and LevelPro CFL Float.

If you are looking for more details, kindly visit our website.

By the end of this blog, you will have a comprehensive understanding of how these sensors work, their unique features, and the benefits they bring to different applications. This knowledge will empower you to choose the most suitable liquid level sensor from Icon Process Controls, ensuring efficient and reliable process control in your operations.

 

Hydrostatic (Submersible) Liquid Level Sensors

Working Principle:
Hydrostatic sensors measure liquid level by detecting pressure changes at different depths.

Model:
LevelPro 100 Series Submersible Level Sensor

The 100 Series Submersible Level Sensor Transmitter measures levels for both corrosive and non-corrosive liquids. It excels in tough industrial applications, unaffected by foam, vapor, turbulence, or condensate.

The 100 Series Sensor sits at the tank bottom, measuring liquid head pressure on its ceramic diaphragm. Its integral molded weight ensures it stays at the bottom, providing accurate, reliable readings. These corrosion-resistant plastic sensors come in PVC, PP, PVDF, and PTFE Teflon®. Each model features a Teflon®-jacketed cable and a Kalrez® O-ring seal, withstanding the most corrosive chemicals. These sensors require no programming, have no moving parts, and feature a non-clogging design. They are the industry&#;s simplest, most reliable sensors for applications unsuitable for ultrasonics.

Bundle the 100 Series with our TVL Local Display and Remote Tank Monitoring Device for a complete tank monitoring system.

Features:

  • Robust design for harsh environments
  • Excellent chemical resistance
  • Integral molded weight &#; no floating
  • Kalrez® O-Rings | PTFE Teflon® Coated Cable
  • Standard 0-34ft range (Others Available)
  • +/- 0.5% accuracy
  • 4-20mA output
  • Industrial heavy-duty design

Benefits:

  • Accurate measurement in challenging conditions
  • Long lifespan with minimal maintenance
  • Suitable for corrosive liquids

Applications:

  • Wastewater treatment plants
  • Chemical storage tanks
  • Groundwater monitoring

Best Use Case:
Chemical storage tanks benefit most from hydrostatic sensors. They provide reliable measurements despite harsh conditions.

Radar Liquid Level Sensors

Working Principle:
Radar sensors use electromagnetic waves to measure the distance to the liquid surface.

Model:
LevelPro ProScan 3 80 GHz Radar Level Sensor

The ProScan 3&#;s 80 GHz high-frequency technology offers precise transmission signal focus. This improves distinction between actual level signals and interference, enhancing measurement reliability and accuracy. The compact ProScan 3 series is ideal for complex applications. Its 80 GHz radar signal penetrates the tank lid, eliminating the need for bulkhead fittings and protecting the sensor from internal conditions.

Features:

  • Bluetooth connectivity
  • 4-20mA | RS-485 communication
  • Not affected by vapor or temperature
  • Measurement under vacuum | high pressure
  • NEMA 4X | IP68 protection
  • Non-contact measurement
  • Insensitive to temperature and pressure changes
  • Ideal for aggressive media

Benefits:

  • Precise measurement in extreme conditions
  • Minimal maintenance required
  • Suitable for various tank shapes and sizes

Applications:

  • Oil and gas industries
  • Chemical processing plants
  • Water treatment facilities

Best Use Case:
Oil and gas industries require radar sensors due to their non-contact measurement and resistance to aggressive media.

Ultrasonic Liquid Level Sensors

Working Principle:
Ultrasonic sensors emit sound waves and measure the time taken for the echo to return from the liquid surface.

Model:
LevelPro UltraPro Ultrasonic Level Sensor

The UltraPro Ultrasonic Level Sensor Transmitters are 2-wire loop-powered sensors that ensure reliable, accurate continuous liquid level measurement. The UltraPro Series offers 4-20mA analog output with HART protocol or RS-485 Modbus, enhancing reliability.

Key Applications:

  • Chemical storage tanks
  • Waste sumps
  • Bulk storage
  • Tanker trucks
  • Day tanks
  • Process tanks
  • Neutralization tanks
  • Wastewater systems

The UltraPro Series integrates seamlessly with most remote instrumentation, including remote displays and monitoring solutions.

Features:

  • Up to 0.15% accuracy
  • Small dead band
  • Simple programming | under 1 minute
  • Loop powered | 2 wire (4-20mA) output
  • Explosion-proof option
  • Non-contact measurement
  • Easy installation and setup
  • Suitable for various liquids

Benefits:

  • Versatile for different applications
  • Low maintenance
  • Cost-effective

Applications:

  • Water reservoirs
  • Beverage industry
  • Environmental monitoring

Best Use Case:
Water reservoirs benefit from ultrasonic sensors due to their versatility and non-contact measurement.

For more information, please visit gallopsensor.

Float Liquid Level Sensors

Working Principle:
Float sensors detect liquid levels based on the position of a buoyant float that moves with the liquid surface.

Model:
LevelPro CFL Float Level Sensor

The CFL Float Level Sensor Transmitter uses a plastic float with an internal magnet. The float&#;s movement directly relates to the liquid level. This movement activates the divider circuit inside the stem, converting it into an analog 4-20mA output signal.

Features:

  • Simple design
  • Reliable and durable
  • Cost-effective
  • Easy to install

Benefits:

  • Long lifespan with minimal maintenance
  • Suitable for various liquids
  • Economical solution

Applications:

  • Fuel tanks
  • Water treatment
  • Industrial processes

Best Use Case:
Fuel tanks are best served by float sensors due to their simplicity and reliability.

Comparison of Applications, Tank Type, Measured Substance, and Best Sensor Choices

  1. Chemical Storage Tanks: Use LevelPro 100 Series for accuracy in harsh environments.
  2. Oil and Gas Industries: Opt for LevelPro ProScan 3 for non-contact and reliable measurement.
  3. Water Reservoirs: LevelPro UltraPro offers versatile and accurate measurements.
  4. Fuel Tanks: Choose LevelPro CFL Float for its simplicity and durability.

Conclusion

Selecting the most reliable liquid level sensor from Icon Process Controls depends on your application needs. Hydrostatic sensors excel in harsh environments, radar sensors handle aggressive media, ultrasonic sensors offer versatility, and float sensors provide simplicity. Choose the right sensor to ensure optimal process control and efficiency.

 

      

Top 10 Level Sensing Technologies

Level sensing is one of the most common functions for process control but it also uses a wide range of different technologies to achieve the same goal; it is therefore important to select the correct design for each application to ensure a reliable and accurate system.

Greg Wainhouse, Midlands Area Technical Sales and Sensors expert at Bürkert UK, offers an explanation on some of the various designs available.

The top 10 level sensing technologies break down like this:

The first distinction to make is the purpose of the level signal &#; is it required to provide a point level such as an alarm or a continuous signal for level monitoring?

1. Float &#; One of the most common forms of point level detection. Although simple in design the float offers a reliable solution. The actual switching mechanism can either be internal and activated by the movement of the float as the level rises or external where a magnet switches a reed contact as the position of the float is moved by the liquid level.

2. Tuning Fork &#; This sensor is set to vibrate at its mechanical resonance frequency and when it becomes submerged in either liquid or solid, the frequency changes. This change is detected and converted into a switching command by the on-board electronics. The discrete sensors discussed so far are often used in conjunction with continuous level detection systems, acting as alarm points for over-filling (high-high) and leak or dry pumping (low-low).

3. Ultrasonic &#; The transducers in these devices emit ultrasonic pulses that are reflected off the surface of the liquid - the time taken is proportional to the distance between the sensor and the liquid. This time is also affected by the temperature of the atmosphere above the media, the soundwave has to travel through and a compensation factor is used by the on-board electronics to derive the precise level within the vessel. In applications involving changing atmospheric gases, foaming liquids or objects in the path of the ultrasonic pulse, reduced reliability and repeatability may be experienced.

4. Radar &#; In principle radar operates in a similar way to ultrasonic, but the pulses travel at the speed of light and again; the reliability and repeatability can be affected - but this time by the dielectric constant of the fluid. However, radar can provide very accurate level data and also compensate for fixed structures within the vessel. The downside can be that the initial cost of the sensor is relatively high, but several manufacturers are making this technology more accessible to the wider market.

5. Guided microwave &#; Also known as guided radar, overcomes many of the initial calibration issues associated with conventional radar sensing by using a cable or rod to guide the signal to the fluid surface and back to the transmitter. This design makes it a lot more reliable than through-air radar or ultrasonic, because the guide provides a more focussed signal path. However, the sensors are limited to the length of cable or rod but with solutions up to 75m there is a wide array of probes to suit many applications.

6. Laser &#; This technology is a flexible, easy to set up and cost effective solution for non-contact continuous level detection of bulk solids and opaque fluids. However, being based on light reflection, it is less well suited to clear liquids, dust & vapour contaminated atmospheres and applications affected by foam.

7. Hydrostatics &#; Hydrostatic pressure is one the most popular level sensing solutions on the market for liquids. Used in vessels open to atmosphere, they are unaffected by changes in media dielectric, atmospheric dust and vapours. However, as they are mounted on the base or underside of the vessel and measure head-pressure via a ceramic or thin-film stainless steel element, the reliability of measurement technique for level will be greatly affected if the media density changes.

8. Differential Pressure &#; Conventional hydrostatic sensors are confined to applications where the storage vessel is open to atmospheric pressure. For situations where a pressurised tank is in use, it is also necessary to measure the atmospheric pressure above the media using a second sensor. The two pressure signals are then evaluated to give the actual hydrostatic pressure of the liquid and the corresponding level. However, this arrangement is subject to errors due to changes in density and temperature but these can only be mitigated by additional compensating factors, such as additional sensors.

9. Capacitance &#; This relatively common approach can be used with solids, liquids and mixed materials which act as a capacitor. The sensor needs to be calibrated to the specific material to account for varying dielectric constants and differences in vessel design. More recent developments have produced a contact-free measurement system that has widened its application. However, the accuracy of a capacitance sensor depends on a homogeneous dielectric constant throughout the storage vessel. The reliability of these sensors can also be heavily influenced by media sticking to the sensitive probe.

10. Load cell&#; The use of strain gauges provides a non-contact measurement system that is built into the support structure of the storage vessel. However, this means that the design and construction of the vessel must account for the use of load cells in order to deliver accurate level measurements. In addition, changes to product density will also greatly affect the reliability of the measurement in the vessel.

Selecting the most appropriate level sensor requires a number of variables to be considered, especially increasingly stringent regulations requiring more precise and reliable level measurement. Improvements to process control enables product quality to be increased while also reducing costs and waste.

Ultimately, the number of different technologies and the increasing amount of sophisticated electronics available to process engineers can make the selection process quite daunting. Fortunately, help is at hand from the experienced engineers at Bürkert which have considerable expertise in designing and installing process control systems for a wide variety of applications.

Want more information on Liquid Level Transmitters? Feel free to contact us.