While we do see a clear winner emerge, remember that carpet vs. flooring truly comes down to personal preference in several categories.
While all the factors on this list are important, how the flooring looks and feels can tip the scales.
Carpet Flooring
Let’s start with the good news. Carpeting is softer on the feet and better at dampening sound—ideal for bedrooms that sit over a living or dining room. That being said, carpeting is not ideal for those with dust mite, pollen or pet hair allergies, as it is trickier to clean.
Above all else, wall-to-wall carpeting faded from the home decor scene in the ’80s. While you’ll still see it in some rooms, a fully carpeted home is uncommon.
Hardwood Flooring
Hardwood floors offer several options. Show off the natural wood on its own or complement a section of a room with a colorful area rug. You can also resurface and stain hardwood when it wears down.
When it comes to comfort, however, it’s all a matter of preference. Some people prefer the smooth feel of hardwood while others will dread the cold against their feet in the morning. Still, the option to add area rugs pushes this category ahead of carpeting.
Best for Appearance and Comfort: Hardwood
There are tricky caveats to caring for both hardwood flooring and carpets, but one can become more of a nuisance over time.
Carpet Flooring
You’ll need a versatile vacuum to properly clean your carpets, particularly one with different pile settings. And if you need to steam clean a stain or odor, you’ll pay between $175 and $600 for the cost of professional carpet steam cleaning or $25 to $90 for a full-day steamer rental.
Hardwood Flooring
On any given week, sweeping or dry mopping is enough to keep hardwood floors clear. Built-up grit can lead to scratches so keeping the floor clean is key. Once a month, use a light water-and-vinegar solution or an approved hardwood floor cleaner to catch caked-on dirt. And while you can vacuum them as well, some vacuums are better for hardwood floors than others.
Best for Maintenance and Care: Hardwood
If you’re tempted by the low upfront costs of carpet, remember to think long-term as well.
Carpet Flooring
Carpet floors last an average of 10 years when well cared for, but you may need to replace the carpeting in as little as five if you have a high-traffic home. After several years, dust, stains and even pests in carpets can lead to replacement.
Hardwood Flooring
The lifespan of hardwood floors can last a full 100 years when maintained properly. While you will need to stain, resurface and replace boards during this time, the full floor can surpass most of the other fixtures in a home.
Best for Lifespan: Hardwood
Advertisement
Have A Stain On Your Carpet?
Find top-rated carpet cleaning contractors that will keep your carpets clean and healthy and help them look new again. See how professional cleaning services can transform your home or business.
Explore OptionsThe cost of hardwood vs. carpet has little competition, but it’s important to look at upfront and long-term costs.
Carpet Flooring
Carpeting can cost as little as $0.65 per square foot and up to $12 depending on the quality and style of the material. Overall, you’ll likely pay just $2.50 per square foot. Keep in mind, however, that you will replace carpeting sooner than hardwood floors and it could affect the resale value of your home.
Hardwood Flooring
There’s no question that hardwood floors are an investment, just one of the cons in the hardwood pros and cons list. New hardwood flooring installation costs between $6 and $23 per square foot, or an average of $12. That being said, quality hardwood floors can transform the design and value of a home and cut down on long-term floor maintenance.
Best for cost: Carpet flooring
There is a wide gap in the ease of installation for these two materials. When seeking speed and simplicity, you’ll find a clear winner.
Carpet Flooring
A professional can carpet a room in a standard workday, often in under eight hours. When there’s no damage to the subfloor, the pro will secure the underlayment and the carpet with adhesive and staples. And while you can install carpeting yourself, it is quite labor-intensive.
Hardwood Flooring
Hardwood flooring installation requires a one-to-three-day commitment and is rarely a DIY project. Once the boards are in place, installers will add several layers of stain, varnish or oil for protection. The trick is to hire the right flooring professional. They should have experience with hardwood and offer a clear estimate upfront.
Best for Installation: Carpet
Battling the elements is a common issue for any part of your home, but both carpet and hardwood floors face unique challenges.
Carpet Flooring
If you spill a glass of water on your bedroom floor, you won’t have to worry about damaging the rug. Synthetic fibers dry quickly and, unlike hardwood, won’t warp. On the other hand, long-term exposure to moisture can cause mold to build up in the carpet’s underlayment.
As for sun and heat, UV rays can both fade and weaken carpeting fibers. You will also need to keep all hot objects away from carpeting, both to avoid scorching and fires.
Hardwood Flooring
Depending on the protective coating on your hardwood floors, you’ll need to move quickly to clean up spills. Your wood can permanently stain, warp or break down when soeaked. If you’re concerned about water damage, consider engineered wood over traditional hardwood.
Both the sun and hot objects like kitchen pans will scorch or alter the color of hardwood floors, but you can sand or stain the floor in most cases. Additionally, hardwood floors do not stand up against pet claws, high-traffic rooms or areas prone to dirt and grit.
Best for Water, Heat and Environment: Carpet
While every circumstance differs, there is a clear winner in this category.
Carpet Flooring
Carpet flooring may not top the home trend charts, but it can improve room design when used properly. Carpeting can dampen sound and make a room feel cozier. It can also transform a finished basement or cover highly damaged hardwood floors.
Hardwood Flooring
Hardwood flooring is an investment for a reason. Its long life and timeless style can increase your home sale value and catch the eye of new buyers. But remember, it’s key to take good care of hardwood to avoid diminishing its value.
Best for Resale Value: Hardwood
Advertisement
Compare Quotes From Top-rated Carpet Cleaning Services Contractors
Free, No-commitment Estimates
Find a ContractorIn the past, many different materials, such as carpet, ceramic or porcelain tile, and vinyl composition tile (VCT), have been the leading flooring materials in residence halls. Today, facility operators are looking for flooring products that are easier to maintain and provide more flexibility and comfort to student residents.
This generation’s college student expects to live in an environment similar to the home they left behind. The type of flooring installed plays a big part in the experience of a building, including sound transmission, temperature and visual appearance.
Housing staff that follow a consistently short replacement cycle are using carpet to add aesthetic interest and to stay on trend with colors and style. Most of the students asked over the past five years have an opinion: carpet feels more like home. The importance of pleasing the student population cannot be overlooked. Students want to know that they are living in residence facilities that are comparable to those of their friends on other campuses.
Carpet can be a beautiful and warm product. Both visual and physical warmth can be elevated by using carpet on bedroom floors. Carpet is superior to most hard flooring products when it comes to thermal resistance (R-value). This can improve the energy efficiency of buildings, offsetting the cost of material and installation for years to come. The benefits realized from this increase in insulating value can be significant. They vary by geographic region and climate, and are affected by how the flooring is used in conjunction with the other materials in the building.
Noise absorption is another factor that is improved with the use of soft surfaces, such as carpet. Quiet spaces enhance comfort and concentration. This is more important than ever because many residence facilities now have a living-learning environment where students and faculty can immerse themselves in learning beyond the classroom. Carpet was compared with hard flooring options in a sound absorption study by the American Society of Interior Designers. Its findings determined that carpet absorbs sound 10 times better than the tested hard flooring options.
Both broadloom and carpet tile have the aforementioned benefits in terms of comfort, but only carpet tile can provide the ease of flooring replacement desired by facilities maintenance personnel at education institutions.
Pressure adhesive carpet tiles are simple to remove and replace. If there is a wear problem in one area, the whole room doesn’t have to be re-carpeted. Innovations in adhesive methods have reduced or eliminated VOC content while increasing the ease of both initial and replacement installation. In addition, today’s carpet tile is more durable than the carpet tile of the past. Advancements in backing have made it as much as 40 percent lighter than traditional carpet tile backing, which makes it easier to transport attic stock from campus storage facilities to residence halls.
Most backings are stronger and have added antimicrobial properties, which help destroy or inhibit the growth of microorganisms, including fungi and bacteria.
Furthermore, many backings consist of high recycled content, making them a more sustainable choice. Products have been improved to eliminate edge ravel and provide better delaminating strength. Some carpet fibers offer a lifetime warranty for staining, colorfastness and abrasive wear.
Many schools prefer to use carpet only in common areas that can be cleaned daily. Advocates of this concept believe that carpet in the student rooms may not be cleaned regularly and can contribute to allergies.
However, an unpublished 2002 study on cleaning and foot traffic emissions found that carpeted areas have a lower concentration of dust and dirt in the air than areas with hard flooring. This is potentially because carpet traps dust, dirt and allergens that are removed with regular vacuuming. Therefore, when cleaned regularly, carpet can provide more healthful indoor air quality than hard surfaces, which allow allergens, dirt and dust to spread each time someone walks through the room.
For many years, vinyl composition tile (VCT) has been the most widely used product for facility managers who didn’t want to use carpet in student bedrooms. Residence hall managers and designers have been working together to find options that can be maintained easily while avoiding materials such as VCT, which have create more of a commercial aesthetic in student living spaces. If you wouldn’t put it in your house, today’s students don’t expect to find it in their residence hall bedrooms.
Luxury vinyl tile (LVT) is being considered and used more widely in residence halls, and in student bedrooms in particular. LVT provides a visually warmer environment, and can be more welcoming and comfortable than standard VCT or sheet vinyl.
With neutral flooring such as a “wood look” LVT, student sleeping rooms can be viewed as a blank canvas. Many students will provide their own area rugs, and this gives them more control over the appearance of their space. It may seem like students would find it an unnecessary annoyance to bring a rug to campus, but students seem happy to be able to choose the color of the floor in their bedroom, just as they would choose their bedspread and lighting.
Because students don’t always cover their own floors, care should be taken in LVT-floored sleeping rooms to provide protection on the legs of furniture so that it doesn’t damage the surface of the flooring.
Hard surfaces provide the potential for a cleaner environment in an application where students may track in dirt or spill things on a regular basis. In many of college and university residence halls, the cleaning staff doesn’t go into the student bedrooms, so flooring that needs less frequent cleaning can be important over the course of a semester. When properly installed, LVT can prevent water from leaking through the joints and down to the substrate, which makes it useful in locations where spills are likely to occur.
It’s easier for a college student to wipe up a spill on a hard surface than to clean up a spill on carpet. Therefore, it’s more likely to be in good shape at the end of the year when the cleaning staff arrives. Also, because students are likely to place an area rug over the hard flooring, their area rugs endure most of the wear and tear from shoes, furniture rearrangement and spills.
LVT products that don’t require a surface treatment now are readily available. The maintenance time associated with sealing and waxing VCT has become a concern of the past for facilities maintenance personnel who work with LVT.
A space can be defined by its flooring. The size and placement of spaces, which is so important in designing residence halls, is of equal importance to the interior finishes installed in those spaces. The materials and colors that finish off the rooms are the final step of a pleasing and cohesive design.
Flooring is one of the components that people see the most and use the most. It helps to set the tone of the living environment. Considering the impact flooring in student bedrooms can have on the students’ home away from home experience, it is critical to the responsive design of a student-life facility.
Storch, associate director for operations, is responsible for overseeing the day-to-day custodial, maintenance and guest operations for the Department of Housing and Residence Life at UNC Charlotte. In addition, he is responsible for renovations and new construction for all housing facilities.
What are your major concerns when choosing a flooring product for student bedrooms in your campus residence halls?
JS: Durability and cleanability of the product is our major concern, which is why we use a solution-dyed carpet product, which enables us to maintain the standards that our students and staff expect. We’re considering vinyl plank flooring because of allergens, but we like carpet in the bedrooms for the comfort.
What is your typical replacement cycle for flooring in these spaces?
JS: Our replacement cycle is six years for carpet and 12 years for vinyl plank. When we install VCT, it never gets changed; we use it for its lifetime, which could be about 20 to 30 years.
What types of products do your students prefer in their bedrooms?
JS: Soft and warm, which is why we tend to go with carpet. We just did a test with two units in Witherspoon Residence Hall, and we got feedback that students like carpet. They don’t want to step onto cold flooring, and they think that having carpet helps keep down noise.
Do most of the students on campus cover the existing flooring with area rugs or leave the flooring you provide exposed?
JS: Yes, they cover hard flooring 90 percent of the time in their bedrooms. The problem is that they tape the carpet down, including using duct tape against the door opening, and after nine months, it’s difficult to remove the tape glue from the floor.
How do you think LVT (luxury vinyl tile) compares with VCT (vinyl composition tile) from a maintenance standpoint?
JS: LVT is light years ahead. I don’t have to do the same kind of extensive cleaning routine I would have with VCT. I can use a scrubbing machine and let it air dry and I’m done. It’s about one-fourth of the labor cost to maintain, and that’s why we’re looking into it for future buildings. I’m also moving from carpet to LVT in the living room areas because of the life cycle cost.
Henning is the assistant director of Housing, responsible for the operation of the comprehensive residential life program at Penn State’s University Park campus. About 13,700 students live on campus, and that includes all first-year students, who are required to live on campus and are guaranteed housing.
What are your major concerns when choosing a flooring product for student bedrooms in your campus residence halls?
CH: The two primary ones are maintenance and the life cycle cost. First, is it a long-term durable product? But, also, how much labor do I have to put into LVT vs. VCT vs. carpet? We also consider cost, the look and sustainability.
What is your typical replacement cycle for flooring in these spaces?
CH: Most of our buildings have vinyl tile in them that is more than 50 years old. We have linoleum more than 70 years old in Atherton Hall. In our more recent projects where we’ve gone with more carpeting in bedrooms, our replacement cycle is targeted for 12 to 15 years.
What type of products do your students prefer in their bedrooms?
CH: We’ve had mixed reviews. We’ve gotten tons of student feedback on the South Halls and other projects, and we’ve had good feedback on carpeting, but we’ve had the strongest positive feedback on the wood-look LVT flooring. For the students, the carpet isn’t as clean of a product as the LVT. Students with allergies and asthma prefer hard flooring because it’s easier for them to clean off dirt and dust more effectively.
Do most of the students living on campus cover the existing flooring with area rugs or leave the flooring you provide exposed?
CH: Most of them cover it. They may bring in small area rugs, but nothing huge in the room. Usually they have a 5x8 area rug to enhance the decor of the room. It’s much easier to keep clean, and the smell is better. In a lot of guys’ dorms with carpet, it smells like a locker room by the end of the semester. We have a carpet vendor that does in-room delivery; students got almost 1,000 rugs from them this year.
How do you think LVT (luxury vinyl tile) compares with VCT (vinyl composition tile) from a maintenance standpoint?
CH: So far, I think LVT is a better product. We haven’t had it in our residence halls long term, but we did benchmark with Michigan State and some other Big Ten schools who have used it. Both VCT and LVT are easy to install, and VCT is less expensive upfront, but with the waxing, sealing, buffing and scrubbing, long-term labor costs are higher with VCT. LVT gives us a better look and feel, plus a better life cycle cost, with less labor to maintain its good looks, and it’s durable.
Randazzo, AIA, PMP. is a project manager and associate at Clark Nexsen, PC, in the Charlotte, N.C. office, where the firm specializes in residence hall design.