What is the disadvantage of glass tables?

I have attached a picture of my hardwood table. One end of the table is shown, because i didn't have the patience to remove all items on it and take the whole table. Basically, the design is the same on both ends of table, and the mid-section of table does not have any designs (ie. curvatures) but straight edged center section. A second picture shows the length, width and thickness of the glass top i want to put on it. I have decided to go with a "pencil-edge shiny finish" for the edge of the table top. I have the following questions:

1. I went to a pro glass cutting shop to order the glass, and the owner has been doing this business for 40 years. So i have to respect his experience. He says tempered glass will shatter, if i bang an object (like a heavy steel vessel used for cooking and serving later) against the edge of the glass top. I understand that tempered glass has a tendency to shatter, but i am wondering if it would be so easy to shatter it. (Note that i want the glass edge to protrude slightly - ie. about 1/8th of an inch - more than the edge of the table. This has been decided after my research on the web, and reading about other people's experience with glass table tops for dinner table). Comments from those with experience having a tempered glass are greatly appreciated.
2. The weight of the glass top will go from 114 lbs to 171 lbs if i increase the thickness from 1/4" to 3/8". The hardwood table has 4 legs on corners, and the center part has 2 leafs that are attached using a sturdy mechanism underneath the table. This is one of the high end tables from Macy's furniture - so the quality is good. But, i wonder if it can stand the weight of a 3/8" thickness.
3. I am considering ordering 3 pieces of glass, rather than one long piece. The advantage of this would be the ease of maintenance if i need to clean underneath. The price might also go down, with reduced size of glasses i would order as the 3 pieces. I will put them on top, and there would be 2 places on table where there would be a gap formed by the glass tops. These 2 places, i plan to cover with decorative table top linen to hide them as well as protect the table from liquid that may spill on the table. The linen would absorb the moisture, and after dinner, i can clean it up in case it is a big spill. The second advantage of this idea is based on the assumption that the reduced size of 3 pieces would make it possible for the table to withstand the weight of 171/3 = 57 lbs, in the center section which worries me. Comments on this idea are appreciated.

I have searched the net, and could not easily find a solution that directly is applicable to my situation. So, i am posting in couple of places, to seek input. Thanks for all feedback.

A dining table is a wonderful gathering spot for family as well as friends. And, it’s probably the first thing your guests notice in your home! You need to choose the focal piece of furniture carefully. It should be beautiful, strong, and the perfect size for your dining area. So, out of glass vs wood dining table, which is better?

Let’s give you the lowdown between a wooden and glass tabletop to help you make the right choice for your family.

Planning a renovation for your dining room? Try our free dining room remodel cost estimator; it’s easy and convenient to use!

Find out your home's credit score

Check your home condition score to find out!

Wood dining table pros

Incredibly durable with a long service period 

A wooden tabletop will serve you for years to come. High-quality wooden furniture can withstand years of wear and tear. Solid oak, for example, is among the most firm and durable ones. It sustains pressure and heat, especially, if its surface has a heat and scratch-resistant finish. No wonder it’s one of the best types of wood for a dining table.

Timeless design

Wood is classic — it will never go out of fashion. Moreover, a wood table, with its unique grain and hardwood tones, brings out a certain appeal that’s inviting and welcoming. It looks incredibly dignified and creates a cozy atmosphere in your home. 

From vintage pieces to sleek contemporary tables — there are many designs out there. Whichever wood species you choose — oak, mahogany, walnut, maple, or teak — ensure that you match the color palette of your dining room decor and design. 

Easy to restore

Because of its durability, hardwood furniture that has been scratched and dented can be repaired. Partially damaged ones can be completely restored. A skilled woodworker with the right tools can bring any vintage or hand-me-down dining table that was scrapped by careless teenagers or scribbled on by rambunctious toddlers back to life.

Wood dining table cons

Heavy and bulky

As firm and durable as wooden dining tables may be, they are also bulky and heavy. If you’re someone who moves around a lot or loves regular furniture rearrangements, it’s not a convenient choice for you.

Expensive option

Genuine hardwood comes at a hefty price, and that’s because each piece of furniture is unique. You can always find cheaper models when you look around for seasonal sales and discounts. But, never compromise on the quality of the wood. 

Susceptible to water damage

Moisture is one of the biggest vulnerabilities of wooden tables. The material can swell if moisture is left to settle on its surface, which eventually can lead the material to weaken and enable mold to form. So, make sure to immediately wipe off spills and other liquid residues to prevent damages.

Vulnerable to scratches and other damages

While the top finish of dining tables can make it resistant to damages caused by daily use, scrapes from sharp or heavy objects can still expose and significantly damage the wood underneath.

Glass dining table pros

Elegant and modern furniture

There’s no denying the elegance and sophistication of a well-maintained glass top dining table. It looks especially fitting in a modern and contemporary house.

Whether it’s an intimate get-together or fine dining — the formal-looking furniture exudes a level of finesse that enhances the overall look of your dining room.

Low-maintenance material

A glass tabletop is easy to clean. Since glass doesn’t absorb or allow liquids to pass through it, when spills occur, you only need to grab a damp cloth rag or paper towel to wipe the mess.

A spray of water is enough to maintain its shine. You don’t even have to use any special cleaning products or solutions. 

Gives an airier look to the dining room

Glass is transparent and reflects light beautifully. No wonder glass instantly lights up a room — giving it an airy and lighter vibe. Moreover, it adds a visual illusion — making your dining space look larger and wider. It’s a boon for small dining rooms that receive less natural light.

Enhances the beauty of your dining area

Since it’s transparent, glass doesn’t block the beauty of the rest of the room’s décor. You can place attractive dining chairs or a beautiful rug under the table and they’ll be fully visible.

Moreover, glass tabletops generally have a wood or metal base. The see-through glass highlights the beauty of the base — bringing out its design, shine, and color. 

Available in different styles

Don’t think of a glass surface as just clear and colorless. It can be frosted and tinted into any color. Furthermore, it can also be cut into almost any shape and is a great choice for a custom-made glass dining table. 

Also, glass tables may feature almost any material as their base. It could be wood, chrome, wrought iron, rattan, or wicker. 

Is quite tough

Thanks to technology, glass dining tables are tough, too. Today, you can find versions with tempered safety glass that are thermally and chemically strengthened. Tempered glass can resist scratches as well as heat, and won’t shatter if knocked.

Glass dining table cons

Delicate and irreparable

Glass is a strong material but it’s not the same as wood or stone. Since the material is breakable and fragile, you need to be extra careful when placing objects on it to avoid damaging the surface or breaking it altogether. Once the glass table is scratched or chipped, you can’t fix it or make it look new again. So, keep those placemats and coasters handy!

Requires regular cleaning

Yes, it’s low maintenance but a glass-top table needs consistent wiping to keep it in pristine condition. Aside from spills, glass is prone to dust, fingerprints, smudges, dirt, and watermarks. Neglected over time, these can tarnish its sparkling appearance and may become foggy.

Can be dangerous

Its fragile material makes glass a safety hazard, especially when you have kids or pets around the house. Once shattered, the glass fragments can be a risk for injury. The sharp corners of glass tables can also harm anyone by accident. If you have small children in the house, it’s best to choose a round or oval shape or those with protected edges for safety.

Demands good flooring and décor

A glass’s transparency can be both a boon and a disadvantage. You can see everything that’s underneath the table! You need an impeccable flooring surface. And, your matching dining chairs must be in good condition too.

Read more: Fabulous Tips for Exceptional Dining Table Dressing

What Are the Pros and Cons of Glass vs Wood Dining Table?

Written by

Oscar Florea.

May 11, 2019

Oscar is a content contributor for Avida’s lifestyle blog Pursuit of Passion. He is an engineer by profession but a multi-potentialite by destiny. Just like a normal dude in a basketball-crazy country, one of his passions is shooting hoops. Grant Hill is the older brother he never had.